9 Employment Contract Red Flags to Check Before You Sign

Most people spend more time negotiating salary than reading the contract that governs the next several years of their career. These 9 clauses can restrict where you work, who you can hire, and what you can build — long after you leave.

Employment contracts are often presented as take-it-or-leave-it documents, especially at larger companies. But many clauses are negotiable, and understanding what you're agreeing to is the first step to deciding whether to ask for changes, sign anyway with eyes open, or walk away.

The 9 Red Flags

1. Overly Broad Non-Compete

A non-compete restricts where you can work after leaving the company — by industry, geography, and duration. Enforceability varies dramatically by state. California bans non-competes almost entirely (Business and Professions Code §16600). Minnesota banned them in 2023. In most other states, courts enforce them if they're "reasonable" in scope, geography, and time.

Red Flag Language"Employee agrees not to engage in any business that competes with the Company, directly or indirectly, anywhere in the United States for a period of 2 years following separation."

"Anywhere in the United States" combined with "directly or indirectly" is overreach for most roles. Acceptable non-competes name a specific geographic radius (typically where you actually worked with clients) and a narrower definition of competition. 12 months is more defensible than 24.

2. IP Assignment That Covers Personal Projects

Intellectual property assignment clauses transfer ownership of anything you create during your employment to your employer. The dangerous version has no carve-out for personal work done on personal time with personal equipment. This can mean a side project, an open-source library, or even a novel you write evenings and weekends theoretically belongs to your employer if it's "related to the Company's business."

Red Flag Language"Employee assigns to the Company all inventions, developments, improvements, and discoveries conceived or developed during the period of employment, whether or not on Company time or using Company resources."
What to ask forA specific carve-out: "This assignment excludes inventions developed entirely on Employee's own time, without use of Company equipment, and not related to the Company's current or demonstrably anticipated business." Several states (CA, DE, IL, MN, NC, WA) actually require this carve-out by law.

3. Mandatory Arbitration

Mandatory arbitration clauses require you to resolve employment disputes through a private arbitrator instead of court. This has two major implications: you give up the right to a jury trial, and — more importantly — you usually give up the ability to join a class action lawsuit. If the company systematically underpays a category of employees, arbitration forces each person to file individually, which makes litigation economically unviable.

Arbitrators are typically paid by the company and handle many cases for the same employer repeatedly. Research on arbitration outcomes consistently shows employees win less often and recover smaller amounts than in court. The Federal Arbitration Act preempts most state efforts to ban mandatory arbitration, though California has repeatedly tried.

4. Equity Clawback Provisions

Equity clawbacks allow a company to take back vested stock or options under specified circumstances. Triggers can include: resigning within a certain period, working for a competitor within 12 months, or a company determination that you violated a policy. The last category — policy violation — is the dangerous one, because it can be invoked after the fact to reclaim equity from someone the company just wants to remove.

Red Flag Language"The Company may, in its sole discretion, require forfeiture of any unvested or vested equity if Employee engages in conduct that the Company determines, in its sole discretion, to be detrimental to the Company."

"Sole discretion" appearing twice in one clause should always prompt a question. Ask specifically what conduct triggers this provision and get any carve-outs in writing.

5. Sign-On Bonus Repayment / Clawback

Sign-on bonuses frequently come with repayment obligations if you leave before a set date, typically 12 to 24 months. The issue is usually in how the repayment is calculated: is it prorated (you repay a fraction based on how long you stayed) or full repayment regardless? Some agreements also require you to repay if you're terminated for cause, even if the termination itself is disputed.

What to negotiatePush for prorated repayment (e.g., you owe 50% if you leave after 6 months of a 12-month vesting period), and ensure the clawback doesn't apply if the company terminates you without cause.

6. At-Will vs. Fixed Term

Most US employment contracts are at-will, meaning either party can end the relationship at any time for any reason (with limited exceptions). If your contract contains specific termination procedures — notice periods, cause requirements — that's better protection than at-will. But watch for contracts that appear to offer cause-based termination protection but then define "cause" so broadly it provides no real protection.

Red Flag Language"For Cause includes, but is not limited to, failure to meet performance expectations as determined by the Company, in its sole judgment."

Undefined or infinitely expandable "cause" definitions eliminate the protection that a for-cause termination clause is supposed to provide.

7. Garden Leave Provisions

Garden leave (more common in UK and financial services contracts, but spreading) means that during your notice period, the company can keep you on salary but prevent you from working — for them or anyone else. You remain an employee on paper but can't interview, join a competitor, or do meaningful work. The notice period effectively functions as an additional, paid non-compete.

If you're in a fast-moving field where 3 to 6 months of idleness creates real reputational and technical obsolescence, garden leave provisions deserve careful scrutiny. Negotiate to shorten the notice period or add a mutual opt-out clause.

8. Non-Solicitation Clauses

Non-solicitation clauses are often attached to or nested inside non-compete provisions. They restrict you from hiring former colleagues or approaching former clients after leaving. The key distinction is scope: "you can't poach people you directly managed" is reasonable; "you can't work alongside anyone who was ever employed by the company in any capacity during your tenure" is not.

Red Flag Language"For 24 months following separation, Employee shall not solicit, recruit, or hire any person who is or was employed by the Company at any time during Employee's tenure, regardless of whether Employee had direct contact with such person."

9. Confidentiality Clauses That Cover Salary

Under the National Labor Relations Act, most employees in the US have the right to discuss wages and working conditions with coworkers. Confidentiality clauses that explicitly or implicitly prohibit salary discussion may be unenforceable and could violate NLRA protections. This matters because pay transparency is how pay inequity gets discovered. Know your rights before agreeing to keep your compensation confidential.

What to Ask Before Signing

Get a second set of eyes on your offer letter

Paste your employment contract into Kaido for a full clause-by-clause analysis — non-competes, IP assignment, arbitration, and more. Know exactly what you're agreeing to before you sign.

Analyze my contract →
Employment Contract Red Flags: 9 Things to Check Before Signing | Kaido